When the first Europeans set sail for North America, they envisioned creating a "city on a hill"—a shining example of moral integrity and collective success for the world to emulate. Inspired by Jesus Christ's words, "You are the light of the world. A city that is set on a hill cannot be hidden," this biblical ideal has profoundly influenced America's historical journey and the evolution of monastic practices within the nation.
In this article, we explore some of the most influential and oldest monasteries in the United States, dating back to the mid-1800s. These communities strive to reflect Christ's light through their way of life, serving as enduring testaments to the biblical metaphor of cities on a hill. Many monastic communities, driven by this ideal, engage actively with society through outreach and service. They offer retreats and spiritual guidance to laypeople, extending their influence beyond their immediate community and embodying the "light" for others to follow.
Founded in 1848, the Abbey of Gethsemani is one of the oldest Trappist communities in the United States. Trappists, or the Order of Cistercians of the Strict Observance (OCSO), follow the Rule of St. Benedict with a focus on strict monastic discipline, silence, and manual labour. Their daily life revolves around the Liturgy of the Hours, with multiple periods of communal prayer throughout the day and night.
A hallmark of Trappist life is an emphasis on silence—not an absolute vow but a practice to foster an environment conducive to prayer and contemplation. Their lifestyle is marked by simplicity and poverty, focusing on spiritual growth rather than material wealth. Trappist communities aim for self-sufficiency, often engaging in agriculture, brewing, and other work to support themselves financially.
While the monastery may not house traditional relics, it is closely associated with Thomas Merton (Father Louis), an influential spiritual writer of the 20th century. Thomas Merton spent significant time in a hermitage on the abbey grounds. The various buildings within the abbey complex, including the cloisters, library, and guesthouses, offer insights into monastic life. The architecture is designed to support a life of prayer, work, and community. These artefacts provide a deeper understanding of his life and spiritual journey.
Visitors can observe the monks as they go about their daily routines, including manual labour, study, and communal prayer. These retreats provide an opportunity to experience the monastic rhythm of prayer, work, and silence.
Holy Trinity Monastery in Jordanville, New York
Holy Trinity Monastery in Jordanville, New York, is a significant spiritual and cultural centre for Orthodox Christians in the United States. Founded by Russian immigrants in the 1920s, it serves as a beacon of traditional Orthodox monasticism. The monastery houses relics of Saint John of Shanghai and San Francisco, a highly revered modern saint known for his miracles, deep spirituality, and missionary work.
The main church, the Holy Trinity Cathedral, is an architectural gem, built in the traditional Russian Orthodox style. Its interior is adorned with beautiful frescoes and icons, creating a sacred atmosphere conducive to prayer. The monastery complex includes several buildings that reflect traditional Russian monastic architecture. These structures house the monks, a seminary, and various workshops.
Holy Trinity Seminary
The monastery's library holds an impressive collection of theological texts, manuscripts, and historical documents. Researchers and visitors interested in Orthodox theology and Russian history will find this resource invaluable. Holy Trinity Monastery offers retreat programs for those seeking spiritual renewal. Visitors can participate in the daily cycle of services, including Vespers, Matins, and the Divine Liturgy.
The monastery provides opportunities for confession and spiritual guidance from experienced monks. This can be a deeply enriching experience for those seeking to deepen their faith. Visitors can observe the daily life of the monks, which includes prayer, manual labour, study, and communal meals. This immersion in monastic life offers a unique perspective on Orthodox Christian discipleship. The monastery often hosts workshops on iconography, providing an opportunity to learn about this sacred art form from skilled practitioners.
Indiana's Abbey
Established in 1854, this Benedictine monastery is known for its seminary and school of theology, which serves the Roman Catholic Church. The monastery is named after Saint Meinrad, a Benedictine monk and martyr. While the primary relics of Saint Meinrad are located in Einsiedeln, Switzerland, the archabbey in Indiana maintains a strong spiritual connection to him through its dedication and traditions.
The Archabbey Church of Our Lady of Einsiedeln blends Romanesque and Gothic styles. Its interior includes colourful stained glass windows, intricate woodwork, and a pipe organ. The complex includes several historically significant buildings, such as the monastery itself, the seminary, and various chapels. These structures reflect the rich architectural heritage of Benedictine monasticism.
The Archabbey’s library holds an extensive collection of theological texts, manuscripts, and historical documents. Researchers and visitors interested in Catholic theology and history.
Saint Tikhon's Orthodox monastery
Founded in 1905, Saint Tikhon's is the oldest Orthodox monastery in North America. It is named after St. Tikhon of Zadonsk and serves as a spiritual centre for the Orthodox Church in America (OCA). The monastery is also home to St. Tikhon's Orthodox Theological Seminary, which has educated many of the church's clergy.
The monastery is named after a revered Russian saint. While the primary relics of Saint Tikhon are in Russia, the monastery maintains a strong spiritual connection to him through its dedication. The monastery houses relics of various saints, including Saint Alexis of Wilkes-Barre and Saint Raphael of Brooklyn.
The main church, dedicated to Saint Tikhon, features beautiful Orthodox iconography, frescoes, and traditional architecture that reflect the rich liturgical heritage of the Orthodox Church. The monastery complex includes several chapels, each with its unique architectural and artistic elements. These chapels provide intimate spaces for prayer and reflection. The monastery possesses an extensive collection of icons, some of which are centuries old. Saint Tikhon's Seminary Library holds a vast collection of theological texts, manuscripts, and historical documents. This resource is invaluable for researchers and those interested in Orthodox theology and history.
The monastery offers retreat programs for those seeking spiritual renewal. Participants can join the monks in their daily cycle of services, including Matins, Vespers, and the Divine Liturgy. Opportunities for confession and spiritual guidance from experienced monks are available, providing a deeply enriching experience for those looking to deepen their faith. The monastery often hosts workshops and lectures on various aspects of Orthodox theology, spirituality, and monastic life. These events provide valuable learning opportunities for visitors.
Adjacent to the monastery is Saint Tikhon's Orthodox Theological Seminary, one of the premier institutions for Orthodox Christian education in North America. Visitors can tour the seminary and learn about its educational programs.
Holy Transfiguration Monastery in Brookline
Founded in 1961, Holy Transfiguration Monastery in Brookline, Massachusetts is known for its strict adherence to traditional Orthodox monastic practices and liturgy. It is a significant centre for Orthodox Christian spirituality and tradition.
The monastery houses relics of various saints and martyrs, which visitors can venerate. These include relics of Saint Panteleimon the Great Martyr and Healer, Saint Nicholas the Wonderworker, and many others. The monastery is known for its collection of miraculous icons, including the wonder-working icon of the Mother of God "of the Sign."
The main church is an architectural gem, designed in traditional Byzantine style. It features stunning frescoes, mosaics, and iconography that reflect the rich liturgical heritage of the Orthodox Church. The monastery complex includes several smaller chapels, each with its unique artistic elements, providing intimate spaces for prayer and reflection.
Holy Transfiguration Monastery maintains a library with a wide range of theological texts, manuscripts, and historical documents, an invaluable resource for researchers and those interested in Orthodox theology and history. The monastery offers retreat programs for those seeking spiritual renewal. Participants can join the monks in their daily cycle of services, including Matins, Vespers, and the Divine Liturgy. Practices: Visitors can observe the daily life of the monks, which includes prayer, manual labour, study, and communal meals. Opportunities for confession and spiritual guidance from experienced monks are available, providing a deeply enriching experience for those looking to deepen their faith.
***
The American dream, once a vision of collective virtue, has become largely secularized, focused on individual achievement and material success. This shift has created a frenetic pace of life, prioritizing career advancement and personal fulfillment. In contrast, American monasticism, though relatively young, offers a counter-narrative, preserving a space for prayer and contemplation amidst the demands of modern society.
Orthodox monastic communities in America have played a vital role in maintaining the contemplative tradition, providing opportunities for inner peace and spiritual growth. They offer a window into the rich heritage of the Orthodox Church, encompassing its architecture, iconography, liturgical music, and the culture of spiritual guidance and eldership.
